Re-roofing vs. Roof Replacement, What Option is best?

Must Read

Heather Jones
Heather Jones
I'm Heather, an author passionate about home improvements. My writing is your guide to making homes better. Let's explore easy ways to enhance your living spaces, from small fixes to exciting projects. Join me on a journey of making your house a cozy and stylish haven.

The roof is an integral part of your home and a worthwhile investment. It helps safeguard all other home systems from harsh weather conditions. A good roof enhances the home’s appeal and increases its value, guaranteeing a good return on investment.

Even with its many benefits, a roof will never last a lifetime. There will come a time you have to decide whether to re-roof or replace it. It is a tough decision because both projects have their perks. Thus, you must choose and work with the best roofing company near you to ensure the job is successful.

There is much to know regarding re-roofing vs. roof replacement to choose the ideal option. This article will give helpful insights and pointers you need. Keep reading.

What Re-Roofing Entails- The Key Things to Know

Re-roofing is an incredible process that involves adding a new layer of shingles over damaged or old shingles. You can term the procedure a repair during DIY because it doesn’t replace the old shingles. 

Re-roofing is only a practical solution for some homes. For instance, adding a new layer may be against the local building codes if your home has two shingles layers. In addition, you have to be cautious as not every type of roofing material, like metal, needs re-roofing. 

Related story:
Why Metal Roofing is the Smartest Choice for Your Home


  • Re-roofing is cost-effective and will save a lot of money as you don’t need to spend on new materials and huge labor costs.
  • It doesn’t take a lot of time to re-roof. 
  • It is a remarkable way to reinforce and strengthen the roof by adding an overlayer. 
  • It cost-effectively rejuvenates the roof and improves its aesthetic value.


  • Requires specific qualifications and has to abide by building codes.
  • It’s a short-term project, and the roof will only last for a while.
  • It increases the weight of the old roof.
  • It eliminates the opportunity to inspect the roof for damages.
  • It can void certain manufacturers’ warranties
  • It can lower the resale value of a home.
  • The double layer of shingles traps heat, decreasing its lifespan.

Roof Replacement

Roof replacement is the most comprehensive and effective way to deal with roof damage. The process involves stripping down the old shingles from the roof and replacing them with new shingles. 

Replacement is the best option if you suspect your roof has underlying damage that needs repair. Roofers will inspect the roof, add new underlayment and water barriers and install new shingles.

Related story:
Constrained By A Draconian Homeowners’ Association? Consider These Workarounds


  • A new roof has a longer lifespan and could last for 20 to 30 years. 
  • Allows keen look and inspection of the roof to spot possible damage or related issues.
  • It increases the home’s value thanks to the roof’s enhanced curb appeal.
  • Get an opportunity to invest in new types of roofing material such as metal, clay tile, or slate.
  • It’s undertaken regardless of the number of shingles installed.


  • A new roof will cost more as you need new materials, cater for labor costs, and haul away debris.
  • It may take longer to install a new roof and handle the whole process.

Which Is the Ideal Option for You?

From a financial perspective, you may decide to re-roof, but the process won’t solve critical problems with your roof. Well, if you look at the bigger picture, roof replacement is the right option. You get a chance to work with experts from the initial stage to the completion of the job.

A new roof will also last longer, and you’ll get a chance to address underlying problems. It is also an excellent opportunity to explore innovative roofing materials and increase the home’s aesthetic value. 

Related story:
5 Common Roofing Issues to Watch Out During This Summer

Final Thoughts

Homeowners have varied perceptions when it comes to re-roofing vs. roof replacement. Weighing the advantages and disadvantages of each process will help make a wise decision. Significantly, be thoughtful about the company you hire. 

Choose reputable roofers who are well-acquainted with roofing issues and eager to deliver quality services. A trustworthy company will ensure timely delivery of services, put safety first, embrace the latest roofing technology, and offer free roofing services estimate quotes. 

Latest Posts

More Similar Articles Like This